The Government has now responded to the Animal Sentience Committee's assessment of the Dogs (Protection of Livestock) (Amendment) Bill, examining whether the government has fully considered the welfare of animals as sentient beings in relation to the Bill which has now become law.
The formal response is as below and can be found online
here:
The Bill amends the Dogs (Protection of Livestock) Act 1953
(“the Act”). The amendments primarily focus on the following key areas:
modernising definitions in, and the scope of, the Act
strengthening police powers to support better enforcement
increasing the penalty for the offence of worrying livestock
on agricultural land to an unlimited fine.
We note the Committee’s view that the Bill clearly enhances
the welfare of livestock by increased protection measures and that adequate due
regard has been given for the welfare of sentient animals in this policy.
We also note the Committee’s concerns about the potential
negative impact of the welfare of dogs where they are seized and detained under
the Act and the associated recommendations made by the Committee.
It is the Government’s view that addressing livestock
worrying and reducing the number of incidents requires a balance to be struck
between a range of factors, including the impact of livestock worrying on
livestock welfare, the loss of livestock to farmers, the emotional impact of
livestock incidents on farmers, dog welfare and the property rights of dog
owners.
The Government considers that the new powers which the
police will have through this Bill to seize and detain a dog where the police
have reasonable grounds to believe there is a risk that a dog could attack or
worry livestock are important tools to help address the risk of incidents of
livestock attacks or livestock worrying.
The Government recognises potential negative impact on the
welfare of dogs that are seized and detained under the Act for extended or
frequent periods. Whilst the exercise of these new powers is a matter for the
police, the Government would only expect dogs to be kennelled during a court
case in exceptional circumstances where there are concerns of the dog attacking
or worrying again.
The Government will keep the implementation of the Act under
review.
We would like to thank the Committee for its consideration
of the Bill.
Presented to Parliament pursuant to Section 3 of the Animal
Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022